Paw Paradox

PHOTOGRAPHY

Jul 29

Paw Paradox is a thought-provoking project by German photographer Caroline Heinecke that explores the surreal history of animal trials — where pigs, insects and even elephants were brought before human courts. By blending AI-generated imagery with documentary photography, Heinecke investigates the shifting boundaries of legal rights, ownership and agency between species.

Photography Caroline Heinecke

The fascinating relationship between humans and animals is reflected not only in the history of their shared development but also in jurisprudence. A particularly peculiar chapter in this regard is the animal trials that encompassed numerous legal proceedings involving animals during the Middle Ages and the early modern period. These trials ranged from murder charges against pigs to ecclesiastical excommunication procedures against grasshoppers and beetles. Even the public hanging of a circus elephant finds its place in the annals of history. These trials, albeit only a small part of the legal history between humans and animals, attest to a fascinating interplay of legal structures and human interaction with animals.

"Paw Paradox" aims to shed light on this complex issue. Through a series of artworks, the project endeavours to provoke contemplation on the intricate dynamics between humans and animals within the legal sphere. Incorporating images partially generated with artificial intelligence, the project further delves into questions surrounding the ownership and copyright of images, adding another layer to the discussion of rights.

In the photographic realisation of this concept, my artistic endeavour was twofold: first, to anthropomorphise animals, presenting them as sentient beings with agency, and second, to portray them as objects, highlighting the historical and legal perspectives that have often relegated animals to mere property.

“Through a series of artworks, the project endeavours to provoke contemplation on the intricate dynamics between humans and animals within the legal sphere.”

Notable trials involving animals

1386, Falaise, Northern France
Pig executed in a show trial

1474, Basel, Switzerland
A Rooster was brought to trial for allegedly laying an unusual egg

1508, Autun, France
Public accusation against rats that threatened crops and food supplies

1544, Beauvais, France
Locusts accused of crop damage

1750, Vanves, Northern France
Female donkey classified as victim in sexual trial

1815, Hartlepool, Northeast England
Costumed monkey lynched as a spy

1916, Kingsport, Southern United States
An elephant cow hung from a crane

2004, Kostanay, Central Kazakhstan
Female bear serves a 15-year prison sentence

About Caroline

Caroline Heinecke (b. 1986 in Nordhausen, Germany) is a Berlin-based photographer specialising in conceptual still life and documentary photography. She studied Visual Communication at Anhalt University of Applied Sciences in Dessau and later refined her artistic approach at the Ostkreuzschule für Fotografie in Berlin. Her work explores the interplay between objects, memory, and human perception, often focusing on how meaning is assigned to seemingly ordinary things. A central theme in her practice is the act of collecting and preserving. In her work on collectors of unusual objects, she shifts the perspective from the individual to the collected, questioning what gives an object value and how human perception transforms the overlooked into something meaningful. Her creative process involves extensive research, fieldwork, and precise visual composition. Whether through staged still lives or documentary-style imagery, she creates visually striking narratives that blur the boundaries between abstraction and storytelling. Her work has been exhibited internationally, including at Les Rencontres de la Photographie d’Arles (2022), Copenhagen Photo Festival (2020), and Villa Grisebach (2024), and has been featured in various publications.

To see more of her work, visit her website or follow her on Instagram

Enjoyed this article?
Like ZERO.NINE on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram

We are proud to present Now You See Me, an editorial by Barcelona-based photographer Sofia Luz. Inspired by the book of the same name, the series explores lesbian identity through striking visual codes, celebrating resilience, visibility and authenticity. Luz’s bold imagery bridges past struggles with present-day expression, offering a powerful ode to diversity and the beauty of living unapologetically.

Blue Valentines

In Blue Valentines, Russia-based artist Ida Anderson transforms the fragile form of a postcard into a vessel for memory, loss and longing. Using the cyanotype process, she renders Moscow in shades of haunting blue — part love letter, part elegy. Juxtaposing tenderness with unease, these images ask what it means to belong, to leave, and to remember a homeland fractured by war.

The Enchancted Ones

In The Enchanted Ones, photographer Stephanie Pommez invites readers into the mystical world of the Ribeirinhos, the river dwellers of the Brazilian Amazon. Shot entirely on 35mm black-and-white film over three years, her work captures the profound bond between nature, myth and community. Centering on traditional midwives, the book unveils a culture where ancestral knowledge, storytelling and the unseen converge, blurring the boundaries between reality, memory and imagination.

A Quiet Homage

A Quiet Homage invites viewers into a contemplative space where art history and contemporary sensibility meet. Drawing inspiration from the harmony and sensual poise of the Italian Renaissance, the series reinterprets classical motifs through a modern lens of sustainability and restraint

Icons of the Wild: Africa in Focus

Icons of the Wild by Swedish photographer Johan Siggesson is a celebration of Africa’s most recognisable animals – elephants, lions, cheetahs, zebras and more – captured in their natural environments without staging or interference. Using low, wide perspectives, Siggesson creates intimate yet respectful portraits that highlight both the animal and its surroundings. This series honours the quiet strength and presence of wildlife, reminding us of what endures and deserves our attention.

Low and High

With a sharp eye for atmosphere and emotion, photographer Burak Yasar turns his lens toward the hidden world of nightlife. His work captures not only the surface energy of music and movement, but also the fleeting, vulnerable moments that emerge in the shadows.

(Some)bodies and (Some)things

Berlin-based mixed media collage artist Rita Evs explores fragility, trauma, and the notion of “home” within a multicultural context. Her work transforms everyday elements into unfamiliar forms, prompting viewers to look anew at what they think they know.

Saintes-Maries-de-la-Mer

Photographer Michéa Nathan captures the soul of Saintes-Maries-de-la-Mer during its annual pilgrimage. Each May, this small Mediterranean village becomes a meeting point for faith and tradition, as thousands gather to honor Saint Sarah the Black in a celebration that unites communities through music, devotion, and shared heritage.

Fighting for Identity

This shoot, Fighting for Identity, draws a parallel between the boxing ring and the everyday battles of living authentically as a transgender woman. The gloves and gear embody societal pressures, while the model’s presence radiates resilience, vulnerability, and defiance. Juxtaposing strength with femininity, the images challenge outdated notions of gender. It’s a story of exhaustion, courage, and ultimate triumph—the universal fight for respect, dignity, and freedom.

The Body Is Not A Thing

Through intimate portraits of actors, dancers, sex workers, and mothers, the work navigates the raw and often uncomfortable space where desire and maternal identity intersect. “The Body Is Not A Thing” is a photographic exploration of the tensions between autonomy, sexuality, and motherhood. Conceived during lockdown and shaped by a political landscape increasingly hostile to women's rights, the project interrogates how women are viewed and how they view themselves in a culture saturated with the male gaze.

Paw Paradox

Paw Paradox is a thought-provoking project by German photographer Caroline Heinecke that explores the surreal history of animal trials — where pigs, insects and even elephants were brought before human courts. By blending AI-generated imagery with documentary photography, Heinecke investigates the shifting boundaries of legal rights, ownership and agency between species.

Days on the Way

Shot entirely on an iPhone inside the women-only carriages of the Tehran–Karaj metro line, Days on the Way is Parastoo Ghahremanifard’s raw and poetic study of in-between moments. What begins as a daily commute unfolds into a meditation on silence, repetition, and quiet defiance. Parastoo documents a suspended reality where exhaustion is etched into faces. In this overlooked public space, the everyday becomes a stage for both weariness and resilience.

ENNUI

With ENNUI, Giuliana Borrelli reflects on the quiet weight of disconnection and the search for self within the spaces we call home. Moving between her childhood home in Italy and her current life in Norway, the project traces a deeply personal journey — one marked by silence, longing, and the slow, transformative act of reclaiming identity.

Soumoud In Dark Times

In Soumoud In Dark Times, Palestinian artist Rehab Nazzal documents life under siege in the West Bank during Israel’s intensified occupation from October 2023 to November 2024. Through 41 poignant images, she captures devastation, resilience, and the visual truth of a people resisting erasure during what many have called a live-streamed genocide.

Bravo

In Bravo, artist Felipe Romero Beltrán crafts a quiet yet powerful meditation on migration, identity, and resilience along the US–Mexico border. Set within the charged landscape of the Rio Bravo, his work captures the tension of waiting, where absence speaks as loudly as presence and time itself becomes a suspended, fragile state.

You Never Walk Alone

You Never Walk Alone, a photo series by Katya Ilina, offers an intimate portrait of London’s K-pop fandom. With warmth and clarity, Ilina captures a vibrant subculture where predominantly female and queer fans reclaim space, challenge gendered biases, and transform shared passion into a powerful expression of identity and joy.

Chrysalis

Chrysalis is a visual series by Georgiana Feidi, a Cluj-Napoca–based artist whose work bridges digital and analogue techniques. Exploring Earth as a living organism in transformation, Feidi blends surreal imagery, post-processing and ethereal tones to reflect on nature’s cycles, human interconnectedness, and the quiet power of planetary renewal.

What truly defines us?

Elzbieta Zdunek’s digital collages explore themes of identity, perception, and the pressure of external judgment. Her work questions how many versions of the self exist, shaped by context and subjective interpretation. Through repeated visual elements, she highlights the cyclical nature of human behaviour, the illusion of choice, and the constant tension between how we see ourselves and how we are seen by others.

Lipsticks

Objects hold stories. Not just in their use, but in their wear, their shape, and the silent they witness. In the intimate space where beauty meets routine, something deeper is revealed. This project by Stacy Greene began with a glance, but quickly unfolded into a quiet investigation of identity, memory, and form.

Die Schlange (The Snake)

With her project Die Schlange, photographer Nancy Jesse presents a hauntingly intimate and cinematic portrayal of life within a surreal architectural organism. The vast Berlin housing complex has been built above a motorway and contains over 1,000 apartments. Her use of light and framing evokes a dreamlike, almost dystopian atmosphere—subtly echoing the building's strange, pulsating core.

Fists of Hope

Fists of Hope, a quietly powerful photo documentary by Olaoluwa Olowu, follows the life of Janet, a young female boxer fighting to rise in Ghana’s male-dominated boxing scene. Set against the raw backdrop of Jamestown, this project captures not only the physical intensity of her training but also the emotional endurance required to survive invisibility, poverty and systemic neglect.

Mi Faddi

Mi Faddi by photographer Aisha Hanan Buhari is a poignant series of conceptual portraits featuring her siblings. Exploring themes of protection, family and privacy, the work reflects the challenges of living in the public eye. Rare nautilus shells are physically placed on top of the images, symbolically shielding the subjects and emphasising their preciousness in both personal and universal contexts.

Liminal Spaces

In her series, Katherine Flynn explores the beauty of liminal space—those transitional states found in abandoned landscapes and within ourselves. Working from a desert junkyard turned creative lab, she repurposes found VW mirrors and doors to frame her images, transforming discarded objects into vessels of memory, stillness, and reflection.

People Watching: Pretzel Cage

With the launch of his new photo studio in Hackney Downs, portrait artist Matt Ford introduces People Watching—an ongoing series of short video portraits featuring the individuals he photographs in the space. We are proud to present the first film featuring performance artist Pretzel Cage.

At Work

Photographer Kip Harris brings At Work to Place M Gallery in Tokyo, showcasing four decades of environmental portraiture. From Morocco to Peru, his images celebrate the quiet dignity of labour, capturing craftsmen, street vendors, and everyday workers immersed in their element. The exhibition runs May 26 – June 1.

The Anthropocene Illusion

British photographer Zed Nelson has just been awarded ‘Photographer of the Year’ for his series ‘The Anthropocene Illusion’. His work focuses beyond the destructive human impact on the natural world, examining the sterile environments humans have built to satiate our craving for natural spaces. We spoke exclusively to Zed about what inspired him, his approach and how the project developed over the course of six years.

America

Photographer Magdalena Correa presents a powerful selection of photographs at Tönnheim Gallery in Carabanchel, Spain. The exhibition revisits her most emblematic projects in Latin America, portraying remote communities through an immersive and poetic lens that captures both the rawness and surreal beauty of life on the margins.

In the Quiet Heart

In the Quiet Heart is photographer Amaan Ali’s personal take on summer camp — not just the fun and games, but the quieter moments that often go unnoticed. His images are tender and observant, capturing kids on the edges: lost in thought, drifting away from the crowd. There’s a stillness to them that lingers — a quiet honesty that feels rare and real.

Paradise

Paradise by Gian Marco Sanna is a haunting visual reflection on humanity's estrangement from nature. Through stark imagery and silence, the project explores our descent from harmony to destruction, questioning freedom, consumerism, and the illusion of progress as we drift further from the origins that once defined our existence.

Why Am I Sad

Why Am I Sad, published by Kehrer Verlag, is Dana Stirling’s moving photographic meditation on depression, memory, and healing. Through quiet still lifes and deeply personal reflections, Stirling invites readers into an honest exploration of mental health, where photography becomes both a question and a lifeline.

Christian Trippe

Paw Paradox

“Through a series of artworks, the project endeavours to provoke contemplation on the intricate dynamics between humans and animals within the legal sphere.”

READ NEXT

The Body Is Not A Thing

Days on the Way